Can a Personal Injury Lawyer Drop Your Case?

# Can a Personal Injury Lawyer Drop Your Case?

Yes, personal injury lawyers can drop your case under certain circumstances, but they must follow specific ethical and legal requirements. Understanding when and why this might happen can help you maintain a good attorney-client relationship and protect your interests.

When Lawyers Can Drop Cases

Ethical Violations by Client

Dishonesty or Fraud:

- Lying about accident circumstances

- Fabricating or exaggerating injuries

- Hiding relevant information

- Providing false documentation

- Committing insurance fraud

Non-Cooperation:

- Refusing to follow legal advice

- Missing important deadlines

- Failing to attend depositions or hearings

- Not responding to attorney communications

- Refusing necessary medical treatment

Conflicts of Interest

Professional Conflicts:

- Representing opposing parties

- Personal relationships affecting judgment

- Financial interests in the outcome

- Previous representation of defendant

Discovery of Conflicts:

- New information about case parties

- Changes in law firm representation

- Merger or acquisition of law firms

- Family or business relationships

Non-Payment of Fees

Fee Agreement Violations:

- Failure to pay agreed-upon costs

- Non-payment of hourly fees (non-contingency cases)

- Refusal to cover case expenses

- Breach of retainer agreement terms

Note on Contingency Cases:

In contingency fee arrangements, attorneys typically cannot drop cases solely for non-payment of fees, since payment depends on case success.

Case Merit Issues

Lack of Legal Merit:

- Discovery that case lacks legal foundation

- Statute of limitations has expired

- No viable legal theory for recovery

- Insufficient evidence to proceed

Changed Circumstances:

- New evidence undermining the case

- Discovery of client fault

- Insurance coverage issues

- Defendant bankruptcy

Legal Requirements for Withdrawal

Court Permission Required

Formal Withdrawal Process:

Once a lawsuit is filed, attorneys must obtain court permission to withdraw from representation.

Required Documentation:

- Motion to withdraw

- Supporting affidavit

- Notice to client

- Proposed order

Ethical Obligations

Professional Responsibility Rules:

- Reasonable notice to client

- Return of client files and property

- Refund of unearned fees

- Protection of client confidentiality

- Assistance with transition to new counsel

Timeline Considerations

Prohibited Withdrawal Times:

- Immediately before trial

- During critical case phases

- When withdrawal would prejudice client

- Without adequate notice

Reasons Lawyers Typically Don't Drop Cases

Financial Investment

Sunk Costs:

- Time invested in case preparation

- Money spent on case expenses

- Expert witness fees

- Investigation costs

Contingency Fee Structure:

- No payment unless case succeeds

- Incentive to see cases through

- Shared risk with client

Professional Reputation

Reputation Concerns:

- Client satisfaction importance

- Referral source relationships

- Professional standing

- Bar association standing

Ethical Obligations

Duty to Client:

- Zealous representation requirement

- Competent counsel obligation

- Loyalty to client interests

- Confidentiality protection

Warning Signs Your Lawyer Might Drop Your Case

Communication Issues

Red Flags:

- Delayed responses to calls/emails

- Cancelled or rescheduled meetings

- Lack of case updates

- Shortened conversations

- Referrals to other attorneys

Case Management Problems

Concerning Behaviors:

- Missed deadlines

- Inadequate case preparation

- Lack of investigation

- Poor negotiation efforts

- Suggestions to settle quickly for low amounts

Financial Discussions

Warning Signs:

- Requests for additional fees

- Concerns about case expenses

- Questions about case value

- Discussions about cost-benefit analysis

How to Prevent Being Dropped

Maintain Honest Communication

Best Practices:

- Provide complete, truthful information

- Disclose all relevant facts

- Update attorney on new developments

- Ask questions when unclear

- Follow attorney advice

Meet Your Obligations

Client Responsibilities:

- Attend all scheduled appointments

- Respond promptly to requests

- Follow medical treatment plans

- Cooperate with case preparation

- Pay agreed-upon costs

Stay Engaged in Your Case

Active Participation:

- Regular case status inquiries

- Document preservation

- Witness identification

- Evidence gathering assistance

- Settlement decision participation

What to Do If Your Lawyer Wants to Drop Your Case

Understand the Reasons

Ask Direct Questions:

- Why do you want to withdraw?

- What can I do to address your concerns?

- Are there ways to resolve the issues?

- What are my options moving forward?

Negotiate Solutions

Possible Resolutions:

- Address communication problems

- Clarify misunderstandings

- Modify fee arrangements

- Improve cooperation

- Set clear expectations

Protect Your Interests

Important Steps:

- Get withdrawal reasons in writing

- Obtain copies of all case files

- Understand case status and deadlines

- Secure new representation quickly

- Preserve evidence and documentation

Finding New Representation

Act Quickly

Time Sensitivity:

- Statute of limitations concerns

- Pending deadlines

- Court hearing dates

- Discovery obligations

Choose Carefully

Selection Criteria:

- Experience with similar cases

- Availability to take case

- Resources for case preparation

- Communication style compatibility

- Fee structure acceptability

Transition Process

Smooth Handoff:

- Request file transfer

- Introduce new attorney to case

- Update court and opposing counsel

- Review case strategy

- Establish new communication protocols

Preventing Future Problems

Clear Expectations

Initial Discussions:

- Case evaluation and prospects

- Timeline expectations

- Communication preferences

- Fee arrangements

- Client responsibilities

Regular Communication

Ongoing Relationship:

- Scheduled case updates

- Prompt response to requests

- Honest disclosure of problems

- Collaborative decision-making

Professional Behavior

Client Conduct:

- Respectful communication

- Reasonable demands

- Patience with process

- Trust in attorney expertise

Legal Remedies for Improper Withdrawal

Malpractice Claims

When Available:

- Withdrawal without proper notice

- Failure to protect client interests

- Breach of professional duties

- Damages resulting from withdrawal

Bar Complaints

Ethical Violations:

- Improper withdrawal procedures

- Failure to return client property

- Breach of confidentiality

- Abandonment of client

Court Sanctions

Judicial Remedies:

- Orders requiring continued representation

- Sanctions for improper withdrawal

- Fee forfeiture

- Professional discipline referral

Conclusion

While personal injury lawyers can drop cases under certain circumstances, they must follow proper procedures and have valid reasons for withdrawal. The best way to prevent being dropped is to maintain honest communication, meet your obligations as a client, and work collaboratively with your attorney.

If your lawyer does want to withdraw, understand the reasons, try to resolve any issues, and quickly secure new representation to protect your interests.

Remember that most attorneys are committed to seeing cases through to completion, especially in contingency fee arrangements where their payment depends on your success.

Important: If you're facing attorney withdrawal, act quickly to protect your legal rights and secure new representation.

---

Facing issues with your current attorney? Contact an experienced personal injury lawyer today to discuss your case and ensure your rights are protected.