10 Things to Check Before Buying Car Insurance

10 Things to Check Before Buying Car Insurance

Learn about 10 things to check before buying car insurance and how it affects your legal rights after a car accident. Get expert advice from experienced car accident attorneys.

FindCarAccidentAttorneys Editorial Team
July 27, 2025
6 min read

# 10 Things to Check Before Buying Car Insurance

Selecting the right car insurance policy is crucial for protecting your financial well-being and ensuring adequate coverage in case of accidents. With numerous insurance companies, policy types, and coverage options available, making informed decisions requires careful research and consideration. This comprehensive guide outlines the 10 most important factors to evaluate before purchasing car insurance, helping you make the best choice for your needs and budget.

1. Company Financial Stability

Insurance company financial strength is the foundation of reliable coverage and claims-paying ability.

Rating Agency Analysis:

- Review AM Best, Standard & Poors, and Moodys ratings

- Look for A++ (Superior) or A+ (Excellent) financial strength ratings

- Check for consistent strong ratings over multiple years

- Verify regulatory compliance and financial examination results

Claims-Paying History:

- Investigate complaint ratios through state insurance departments

- Check for timely claims processing and payment records

- Review customer satisfaction surveys and ratings

- Assess company stability and long-term viability

2. Coverage Types and Limits

Understanding what coverage is included and the policy limits determines your protection level.

Required Coverage Components:

- Bodily injury liability per-person and per-accident limits

- Property damage liability coverage amounts

- Personal injury protection (PIP) availability and limits

- Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage requirements

Optional Coverage Considerations:

- Collision damage coverage for your own vehicle

- Comprehensive coverage for theft and weather damage

- Medical payments coverage for medical expenses

- Rental reimbursement and roadside assistance options

3. Deductible Amounts

Deductibles represent the amount you pay out-of-pocket before insurance coverage begins.

Deductible Selection Factors:

- Balance premium costs with out-of-pocket risk tolerance

- Consider emergency fund size and financial readiness

- Evaluate accident frequency and potential claim likelihood

- Compare deductibles across similar coverage options

- Remember higher deductibles generally mean lower premiums

Multiple Deductible Management:

- Understand separate deductibles for different coverage types

- Calculate total out-of-pocket exposure for claims

- Plan for deductible payment timing and methods

- Consider guaranteed asset protection needs

4. Premium Costs and Payment Options

Premium costs should align with your budget while providing adequate coverage value.

Cost Comparison Strategies:

- Obtain quotes from multiple insurance providers

- Compare identical coverage limits and deductible amounts

- Calculate annual vs. monthly payment cost differences

- Factor in discount opportunities and availability

- Consider loyalty and bundling discount potential

Payment Flexibility Options:

- Explore installment payment plan availability

- Check for automatic payment discount opportunities

- Review electronic payment convenience fees

- Consider annual payment vs. monthly premium differences

5. Discount Availability

Multiple discount opportunities can significantly reduce premium costs.

Common Discount Categories:

- Safe driver record and accident-free driving incentives

- Multi-vehicle and multi-policy bundling savings

- Professional organization and alumni association discounts

- Anti-theft device and safety feature installation credits

- Completion of defensive driving course reductions

Senior and Demographic Discounts:

- Age-based discount availability and eligibility

- Mature driver safety course completion incentives

- Low-mileage and retired driver program benefits

- Family plan and multi-driver household savings

6. Claims Service Quality

Insurance company claims handling determines how well your claim will be processed.

Service Quality Indicators:

- Average claims processing time statistics

- Customer satisfaction rating comparisons

- Independent review organization assessments

- Complaint resolution effectiveness measurements

First-Notice-of-Loss Response:

- Initial contact response time expectations

- Claim representative availability and accessibility

- Documentation requirement clarity and reasonableness

- Status update frequency and communication quality

7. Underwriting and Rating Factors

Understanding how insurance companies determine rates helps set realistic expectations.

Personal Rating Factors:

- Driving record and accident/violation history

- Vehicle type and safety rating considerations

- Annual mileage and commuting distance factors

- Credit score impact on rating calculations

- Geographic location and risk assessment factors

Rating Stability Considerations:

- Rate increase limitations and predictability

- Claims history impact duration assessment

- Renewal guarantee availability evaluation

- Rate comparison methodology understanding

8. Policy Terms and Exclusions

Reading and understanding policy terms prevents unpleasant surprises during claims.

Critical Policy Provisions:

- Coverage territory and geographical limitations

- Vehicle usage restrictions and permitted drivers

- Excluded perils and coverage limitations

- Renewal and cancellation provision clarity

Exclusion Awareness Areas:

- Intentional damage and criminal activity exclusions

- Mechanical breakdown and wear-and-tear limitations

- Custom equipment and modification coverage gaps

- Business use and commercial driving restrictions

9. Customer Service Reputation

Insurance company customer service affects your overall experience and claims handling.

Service Quality Assessment Methods:

- Review independent customer satisfaction surveys

- Check Better Business Bureau complaint records

- Examine online review platform ratings and comments

- Assess social media presence and responsiveness

Digital Service Capabilities:

- Online policy management platform functionality

- Mobile application usability and feature set

- Self-service claim filing option availability

- Digital document storage and access capabilities

10. Additional Services and Benefits

Consider valuable extra services that enhance policy value beyond basic coverage.

Emergency and Assistance Services:

- Roadside assistance coverage extent and limitations

- Emergency roadside service response time guarantees

- Towing service coverage distance and cost limits

- Battery jump-start and tire change service inclusion

Appraisal and Advisory Services:

- Accident forgiveness program availability

- Rental vehicle reimbursement coverage

- Diminished value coverage inclusion

- Accident forgiveness provision details and limitations

Policy Comparison and Selection Strategy

Comprehensive Evaluation Framework

Coverage Adequacy Assessment:

- Personal asset protection requirement calculation

- Family size and protection need consideration

- Vehicle value and replacement cost evaluation

- Future medical expense and income loss protection

Cost-Benefit Analysis:

- Premium cost vs. coverage level comparison

- Deductible amount impact on total cost evaluation

- Discount utilization and savings maximization

- Service quality and reputation factor integration

Professional Advice and Consultation

Insurance Agent Benefits

Independent Agent Advantages:

- Multiple company access and objective recommendations

- Personalized coverage analysis and recommendation

- Ongoing policy review and adjustment services

- Claims assistance and dispute resolution support

Online Quote Service Utilization:

- Broad market comparison capability facilitation

- Immediate quote availability and comparison tools

- Educational resource access for informed decisions

- Independent review and rating system utilization

Long-Term Policy Management

Annual Policy Review Importance

Coverage Needs Reassessment:

- Life change impact evaluation (marriage, children, retirement)

- Vehicle changes and additional vehicle considerations

- Income level changes and coverage adjustment needs

- Health condition changes affecting medical coverage needs

Market Comparison Maintenance:

- Annual quote shopping for competitive rate verification

- Policy feature comparison with current offerings

- New coverage option availability assessment

- Claims experience and satisfaction review implementation

Conclusion: Informed Insurance Decisions

Choosing the right car insurance policy requires systematic evaluation of company stability, coverage adequacy, pricing structure, and service quality. By carefully checking these 10 essential factors, you can select optimal protection that balances comprehensive coverage with affordable premiums.

Remember that car insurance is a significant ongoing expense that provides critical financial protection. Taking time to research and compare options ensures you receive appropriate coverage at a competitive price while working with a reputable, responsive insurance provider.

Consider consulting with an insurance professional or using online comparison tools to evaluate multiple insurance options. Armed with comprehensive information about these key factors, you can make confident, informed decisions that protect your financial well-being and provide peace of mind on the road.

Your insurance policy should evolve as your life circumstances change. Regular policy reviews and market comparisons ensure continued optimal protection and value for your insurance investment.

You may be interested in